"A real window on to history in an engaging love story. I really enjoyed the attention to detail in this novel, which gave a real sense of place and time to an exciting romp of a love story. It took me to a place in history, about which I previously knew very little, and really set the scene to enjoy the twists in the unfolding story. A good read!"
[McFarlane - Amazon reader]
"History meets Fiction in a seamless blend! Love it! - A feel good story in which we catch up with our old friend John whilst using fiction to redeem one of the biggest injustices in American history. Once again Carol M Mottershead makes history her playground in this amazingly detailed retelling of historical events. C'est Magnifique!"
[Kindle reader]
"Great follow on book, so captivating. Not disappointed, just as an enjoyable read as "Joan put in your happy face". I enjoyed the relationships developing, the historical element made me think and reflect on my understanding. Another fantastic read, I hope there is more to follow."
[LizFev - Amazon 27 July 2023]
"What a nice love story, Carol. A happy ending for all. Medicine woman's drops gave Ann life. Hugh and Elizabeth - John and Ann."
[Tom Edwards - Emailed review]
"A feel good story in which we catch up with our old friend John whilst using fiction to redeem one of the biggest injustices in American history. Once again Carol M Mottershead makes history her playground in this amazingly detailed retelling of historic events. C'est Magnifique!"
[Alun Littlefair - Goodreads 30 Sept 2023]
"Carol, admit it you didn�t write Memories Of..., you summoned it. Because, honestly, what kind of sorcery makes readers feel like they�ve been shipwrecked in 1654, clutching a fever ridden love story while yelling �JOHN, DON�T GO INTO THE FOREST!� at their Kindle like it�s a horror movie? The way you wrote John Punch�s torment torn between love and survival feels so cinematic it deserves its own historical drama series. You didn�t just create a character; you crafted a man who�s both broken and brave, desperate yet devoted. That�s the kind of emotional torment readers beg for while pretending they�re fine. And knowing you, Carol the woman who once blurred the line between herself and her own character Joan (your sons had to literally remind you, �You are not Joan!� ) it makes total sense. You live inside your stories. You research, dream, and probably argue with your characters over breakfast. You don�t write books; you haunt them.
That intensity is why Memories Of... hits so hard. It�s not just historical fiction; it�s an ache disguised as a journey. The smell of sea salt, the pounding of John�s heart, the impossible choice between love and death your storytelling wraps readers in it like fog rolling over Gwynn�s Island. [With slightly unhinged admiration, Donna J Platt 2025]